Q:Is the Pirani vacuum gauge significantly affected by the type of gas? Is correction necessary when measuring different gases?
A:It has a significant impact.The Pirani gauge is a thermal conductivity vacuum gauge. Its measurement principle is as follows: Heat is transferred to the surrounding gas through the heating filament. The higher the gas pressure and the more molecules there are, the faster the heat transfer, the lower the temperature of the heating filament, and the lower the electrical resistance. Different gases haveThe thermal conductivity varies greatlyTherefore, at the same pressure, the readings of the Pirani vacuum gauge will vary significantly depending on the type of gas. Pirani gauges are typically calibrated usingnitrogen (N₂) or airAs a calibration reference, when measuring other gases such as helium, hydrogen, and argon, it is necessary to usegas correction factorfor conversion, or recalibrate for that gas. If the type of gas changes frequently or is unknown, it is recommended to use aCapacitance diaphragm vacuum gauge, which directly measures pressure regardless of the type of gas.
The sensor of the Pirani vacuum gauge is a heated filament that conducts heat through gas molecules. Different gases have different molecular structures, molecular weights, and thermal conductivities, resulting in significant differences in heat transfer efficiency. The table below lists the relative thermal conductivities of common gases at room temperature (with nitrogen as 1.00):
| Gas | Relative thermal conductivity (N₂=1.00) | Pirani Reading Trend | Correction Factor Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nitrogen (N₂) | 1.00 (reference) | Reference | 1.00 |
| Air | ≈1.00 | Near baseline | ≈1.00 |
| Helium (He) | ≈5.7 | Reading too low (heat transfer too fast) | ≈0.18 |
| Hydrogen (H₂) | ≈7.0 | Reading is too low | ≈0.14 |
| Argon (Ar) | ≈0.67 | Reading is too high (heat transfer is too slow) | ≈1.50 |
| Carbon dioxide (CO₂) | ≈0.62 | Reading is too high | ≈1.60 |
| Sulfur hexafluoride (SF₆) | ≈0.35 | Readings are significantly higher than expected | ≈2.80 |
It can be seen that the thermal conductivity of helium and hydrogen is much higher than that of nitrogen, and the readings measured by the Pirani vacuum gauge will be significantly lower; whereas for gases with low thermal conductivity such as argon, carbon dioxide, and sulfur hexafluoride, the readings will be significantly higher. If no correction is made, the measurement error may reachseveral times or even an order of magnitude。
Correction factor calculation formula:
PActual = PReading × K
PActual:Actual pressure value
PReading:Pirani vacuum gauge reading (calibrated with N₂)
K:Correction factor for the gas
Example:A Pirani vacuum gauge calibrated with N₂ measures argon gas with a reading of 10 Pa. From the table, the correction factor for argon, K ≈ 1.50, so the actual pressure ≈ 10 × 1.50 = 15 Pa. If no correction is applied, the error can be as high as 50%.
| Operating Conditions | Recommended Solution | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Gas type is fixed and known (e.g., N₂, air) | Pirani vacuum gauge | Low cost, readings are directly usable |
| Fixed gas type, but not N₂ (e.g., Ar, He) | Pirani vacuum gauge + correction factor or calibration for the specific gas | Economically viable, requires manual conversion or custom calibration |
| Frequent switching of gas types | Capacitance diaphragm vacuum gauge or compound vacuum gauge with gas switching | Avoid frequent conversions and human error |
| Mixed gases or unknown gas composition | Capacitance diaphragm vacuum gauge | Directly measures absolute pressure, regardless of gas type |
| Corrosive gases | Corrosion-resistant capacitance diaphragm vacuum gauge | The Pirani heating filament is susceptible to corrosion, and a corrosion-resistant diaphragm can be used for the capacitance diaphragm. |
Before selecting a Pirani vacuum gauge, the following must be confirmed:
Gas type:Whether it is a single gas or a gas mixture, and whether there are frequent switches.
Measurement range:Select a Pirani vacuum gauge with an appropriate measuring range to cover the required vacuum range.
Accuracy requirements:Whether gas correction is required, and whether high-precision measurement is required.
Corrosiveness:Whether the gas is corrosive and whether a corrosion-resistant vacuum gauge is required.
Interfaces and Signals:Flange interface, output signal type, and whether a controller is required.
Environmental Conditions:The effects of temperature, humidity, vibration, etc., on measurements.
Regarding the impact of gas types on vacuum measurements,GN Instruments Instrumentation Co., Ltd.can offer the following product solutions:
| Product Series | Measurement Range | Gas influence | Applicable Scenarios |
|---|---|---|---|
| CX-PRN Pirani Vacuum Gauge | 10⁻¹~10⁵ Pa | Affected by gas type, correction required | Rough and low vacuum monitoring, scenarios with fixed or correctable gas types |
| CX-PRN14 cold cathode Compound Vacuum Gauge | 10⁻⁵~10⁵ Pa | The low vacuum section is affected by gas, and the gas can be switched via the controller. | Wide-range monitoring, scenarios with minimal variation in gas types |
| CFG-500 Capacitance Diaphragm Gauge | 1~10⁵ Pa | Independent of gas type | Frequent changes in gas types, mixed gases, precision vacuum control |
Engineers will recommend suitable vacuum gauge models and configuration solutions based on your actual gas types, measurement range, accuracy requirements, and operating conditions. For scenarios where the gas type is fixed and can be corrected, a Pirani vacuum gauge is recommended; for scenarios where the gas type changes frequently or involves mixed gases, a capacitance diaphragm vacuum gauge is recommended. If necessary, we can provide prototype testing services to verify the measurement performance under actual operating conditions.